DaimlerChrysler To Appeal Ruling In Freightliner Case
Posted on December 18, 2006
DaimlerChrysler said it will appeal the ruling of a U.S. court that ordered it and its heavy truck-making unit Freightliner LLC to pay hundreds of millions of dollars in a tangled multinational fraud case, a DaimlerChrysler spokeswoman said. The Oregonian newspaper reported that a Multnomah County Circuit Court jury had found Freightliner liable for shifting assets among several of its divisions in a bid to avoid a legal judgement. Freightliner and its parent company, DaimlerChrysler North American Holding Corp., were ordered to pay $350 million in punitive damages -- an amount believed to be the largest such award ever in Oregon, the paper said.
The decision follows a British court ruling in the case last year ordering Freightliner, headquartered in Portland, to pay at least $489 million to German truck maker MAN AG. The case goes back to suspected accounting fraud in the 1990s at U.K. truck manufacturer ERF, now owned by MAN. MAN bought ERF in March 2000 from Western Star Holdings Ltd., a Canadian truck maker. Western Star in turn was bought by Freightliner in late 2000.
The suspected accounting fraud stems from before Freightliner was associated with ERF, but MAN AG claims it did not discover the fraud until 2001. MAN filed suit against Freightliner in a British court in 2002, a move that linked the truck company and its corporate parent to the case.
In 2005, a London judge found for MAN and issued an interim award. The British court backed MAN's claim that ERF's financial controller had defrauded MAN through an accounting scam carried out over several years that went undetected by auditors. MAN said in the earlier London trial that it bought ERF thinking it was a profitable company, but subsequently found it was losing money.
"We are very disappointed by the jury's ruling," a DaimlerChrysler spokeswoman said, adding that Freightliner had never attempted to hide assets from MAN. Daimler's appeal on the ruling would be heard next year, she said. "We are confident that we ultimately will be able to successfully show that there was absolutely no misconduct on Freightliner's part," the spokeswoman said.